
Chest Fly vs Chest Press
Short answer
Do both, but don't swap one for the other: press heavy first, then fly lighter. The machine chest press is your main chest builder, with your triceps and front delts helping you move more weight. The chest fly works the chest on its own through a long stretch at the bottom, which is why it needs a much lighter weight.
Chest Fly
Lean on the chest fly when you want more chest work without more triceps work, for example after a hard press or when your triceps are still sore. Keep the reps slow and controlled.
How to do itChest Press
Lean on the machine chest press when you want to move more weight, take sets close to failure safely, or learn the pressing pattern. It's the one to do first in the workout.
How to do itHow they differ
| What differs | Chest Fly | Chest Press |
|---|---|---|
| Movement | Chest Fly: Arms sweep in a wide arc, elbows held in a slight bend | Chest Press: Push straight out, elbows bend and straighten |
| Main muscles | Chest Fly: Chest | Chest Press: Chest, triceps and front delts |
| Load | Chest Fly: Light: nearly straight arms make small dumbbells feel heavy at the bottom | Chest Press: Heavy: the machine handles the balance |
| Typical reps | Chest Fly: 10 to 15 | Chest Press: 8 to 12 |
| Order in the workout | Chest Fly: Second, after the press | Chest Press: First, while you're fresh |
| Equipment | Chest Fly: Dumbbells and a bench, or a pec deck or cables | Chest Press: A chest press machine |
A week that uses both
- Chest day 1 · Machine chest press: 3 sets of 6 to 8, heavy. Then chest fly: 2 sets of 12 to 15, light, lowering until your hands are level with your chest.
- Chest day 2 · Machine chest press: 3 sets of 10 to 12. Then chest fly: 3 sets of 10 to 12, taking about three seconds on the way down.
- Next week · Same plan. Add weight to the press first. Add weight to the fly only when every rep stays smooth at the bottom.
The weights don't carry over
Your press weight tells you nothing about your fly weight. On the fly, the dumbbells sit at the end of nearly straight arms, so they feel far heavier at the bottom, where your chest is stretched, than the same weight would on a press. Most people fly with much less than they press, and a machine's stack number doesn't compare to a dumbbell anyway. Start very light and add weight only while you can control the bottom of every rep.
If something hurts
A strong stretch across the chest at the bottom of the fly is normal. A pinch or sharp pain at the front of the shoulder is not: shorten the range, keep the bend in your elbows and go lighter. Stop and get help if pain is sharp, lasting or getting worse.
What the research says
We found no study that compares the machine chest press with the fly directly. This one compared a barbell bench press with the dumbbell fly: 17 resistance-trained men lifted their 6-rep max in both. The bench press showed higher chest, front delt and triceps activity, and the biceps were more active in the fly. The authors concluded both exercises can be included, with more emphasis on the press.
Source: Solstad et al., 2020, Journal of Sports Science and Medicine
Workouts with Chest Fly or Chest Press
Questions
Common questions about Chest Fly and Chest Press.
Do I need chest flys if I already do the chest press?
If a bigger chest is the goal, adding a fly is worth it. The press does most of the work, with help from your triceps and front delts, and it produced more chest activity than the fly in a study of trained men (Solstad et al., 2020). The fly adds work for the chest alone at a long stretch. Two or three sets after your press is enough for most people, with dumbbells, a pec deck or cables.
Why should the chest fly be lighter than the chest press?
Because of where the fly gets hard. With your arms nearly straight, the weight sits far from your shoulders, and it's hardest at the bottom, where your arms are wide and your chest is at its longest stretch. A heavy weight there puts a lot of strain on the chest and the front of the shoulder. Use a weight you can lower slowly and lift smoothly for 10 to 15 reps.
Why do I feel chest flys in my shoulders?
Usually the dumbbells go too low, your elbows bend and straighten so the fly turns into a press, or your shoulders roll forward. Keep the same slight bend in your elbows, pull your shoulder blades back, and stop when your hands are level with your chest. A stretch across the chest is normal, but a sharp or pinching pain in the shoulder is not. Go lighter and shorten the range first, and stop and get help from a doctor or physical therapist if the pain is sharp, lasting or getting worse.
Should I do chest flys before or after the chest press?
After, for most people. In a study of 13 men with recreational lifting experience, doing the pec deck to failure right before the chest press didn't make the chest work harder during the press; the triceps did more instead (Gentil et al., 2007). The authors suggest starting with the exercise you most want to perform well, which for most people is the press.
More comparisons
- Bench Press vs Chest Press
- Deadlift vs Romanian Deadlift
- Good Morning vs Deadlift
- Hammer Curl vs Preacher Curl