
Good Morning vs Deadlift
Short answer
Do both, on different days, but not as equals. The deadlift is your main heavy pull: it builds strength from the floor, with your legs, hips and back sharing the work. The good morning is a lighter accessory that trains your hamstrings, glutes and lower back to hold a hip hinge with the bar on your back.
Good Morning
Lean on the good morning when you want to strengthen your hamstrings and lower back with light weight, or when you have a squat rack but no room or plates to pull from the floor.
How to do itDeadlift
Lean on the deadlift when you want to build overall pulling strength and lift the most weight, with your quads, glutes, hamstrings and back working together.
How to do itHow they differ
| What differs | Good Morning | Deadlift |
|---|---|---|
| Bar position | Good Morning: On your upper back, like a squat | Deadlift: In your hands, starting on the floor |
| Knees | Good Morning: Nearly straight, with a soft bend | Deadlift: Bend a lot at the start, so the quads help |
| Main muscles | Good Morning: Hamstrings, glutes and lower back | Deadlift: Glutes, hamstrings, quads and back |
| Weight used | Good Morning: Light, well below your deadlift | Deadlift: The heaviest lift in most programs |
| Hardest point | Good Morning: The bottom, with your torso leaning far forward | Deadlift: Breaking the bar off the floor |
| Grip | Good Morning: Just steadies the bar | Deadlift: Has to hold the full weight every rep |
A week that uses both
- Lower day 1 · Deadlift: 3 sets of 5. End each set with one or two good reps left.
- Lower day 2 · Good morning: 3 sets of 8 to 10 with a light bar, taking about three seconds on the way down.
- Next week · Same plan. If your lower back is still tired from day 1, drop a set of good mornings or skip them that week.
The weights don't carry over
Good mornings use far less weight than deadlifts. The bar sits on your upper back, far from your hips, and in one study the same light load made the hips work harder in a good morning than in a deadlift. Never bring your deadlift weight across. Start with an empty bar, stay well below what you'd use for a Romanian deadlift, and add weight only while your back stays flat on every rep.
If something hurts
Your lower back muscles work hard in a good morning, so some effort there is normal. Keep your back flat, push your hips back, and stop leaning where your hamstrings are fully stretched, even if your torso is still well above parallel. If you feel sharp pain, or pain that lasts or gets worse, stop and get it checked by a qualified professional.
What the research says
13 people did good mornings with 25% of their body weight on the bar and deadlifts with 25% and 50%. At the same 25% load, the good morning put a larger turning force (moment) on the hip than the deadlift and the same one on the lower spine (L4/L5). The knees bent about 5 degrees in the good morning and over 100 in the deadlift.
Source: Schellenberg et al., 2013, BMC Sports Science, Medicine and Rehabilitation
Workouts with Good Morning or Deadlift
Questions
Common questions about Good Morning and Deadlift.
Can good mornings replace deadlifts?
Not fully. Both train the hip hinge and your hamstrings, glutes and lower back, but the good morning uses far less weight, involves little knee bend, and never pulls from the floor. Use it as an accessory next to the deadlift, or as a short-term swap when you can't deadlift, for example when there's no space to pull from the floor.
Are good mornings bad for your lower back?
Not when the weight is light and your back stays flat. Your lower back muscles hold your spine still in this lift, so feeling them work is expected. Pain is different. Lighten the bar, shorten how far you lean, slow down, and keep a soft bend in your knees. If the pain is sharp, lasting or getting worse, stop and get it checked by a qualified professional.
Why do I feel good mornings in my lower back instead of my hamstrings?
Usually you're bending at the waist instead of pushing your hips back, or leaning further than your hamstrings allow, so your back rounds to get there. Push your hips back as if closing a door behind you, keep your shins close to vertical, and stop when you feel a strong stretch in your hamstrings. Some lower back effort is still normal in this lift.
Should beginners do good mornings or deadlifts?
Start with the deadlift, or the Romanian deadlift if pulling from the floor feels awkward. Add good mornings once pushing your hips back feels natural, beginning with an empty bar. Filming a set from the side helps you check that your back stays flat.
More comparisons
- Bench Press vs Chest Press
- Chest Fly vs Chest Press
- Deadlift vs Romanian Deadlift
- Hammer Curl vs Preacher Curl