Deadlift and Romanian Deadlift, side by side

Deadlift vs Romanian Deadlift

Short answer

Do both, and alternate them. The deadlift builds whole-body pulling strength from the floor. The Romanian deadlift builds the hamstrings and glutes through a long, controlled stretch. Rotating them gives you both without repeating the same hard session every time.

Deadlift

Lean on the deadlift when you want to move the most weight and build strength off the floor, with your quads and upper back sharing the work.

How to do it

Romanian Deadlift

Lean on the Romanian deadlift when your hamstrings and glutes are the target, when you want an easier day for your lower back, or while you're still learning to hinge.

How to do it

How they differ

StartsDeadlift: Bar on the floor, every repRomanian Deadlift: Bar at your hips, lowered from the top
Range of motionDeadlift: Floor to standingRomanian Deadlift: Hips to about mid-shin, or wherever your hamstrings run out of stretch
KneesDeadlift: Bend a lot at the start, so the quads helpRomanian Deadlift: Stay softly bent the whole set
Main musclesDeadlift: Glutes, hamstrings, quads and backRomanian Deadlift: Hamstrings and glutes
Hardest pointDeadlift: Breaking the bar off the floorRomanian Deadlift: The bottom, where the hamstrings are stretched

A week that uses both

  1. Lower day 1 · Deadlift: 3 sets of 5. End each set with one or two good reps left.
  2. Lower day 2 · Romanian deadlift: 3 sets of 8 to 10, taking about three seconds on the way down.
  3. Next week · Same plan. If your lower back is still tired from day 1, swap the days.

The weights don't carry over

Don't bring your deadlift weight to the RDL. Without the push from the floor and the help of your quads, most people handle noticeably less. Start well below your deadlift weight and add load only while your back stays flat and the bar stays close to your legs.

If something hurts

Effort in the hamstrings and glutes is normal. Pain in the lower back usually means the bar drifted forward or your back rounded, so lighten the bar and shorten the range. Stop and get help if the pain is sharp or keeps coming back.

What the research says

21 men lifted the same load in both lifts. The conventional deadlift showed more quadriceps and glute activity than the Romanian deadlift, and hamstring activity did not differ significantly.

Source: Lee et al., 2018, Journal of Exercise Science & Fitness

Questions

Common questions about Deadlift and Romanian Deadlift.

Is the Romanian deadlift better for the glutes than the deadlift?

Not in the direct comparison we found: at the same load, the conventional deadlift showed more glute activity (Lee et al., 2018). The RDL still trains the glutes hard, and its long stretch makes it a strong hamstring exercise. Doing both covers more than picking one.

Can I do deadlifts and RDLs in the same week?

Yes. Put them on different days, keep the deadlift heavier with fewer reps and the RDL lighter with more reps. If your lower back still feels tired on RDL day, trim a set or swap the order of the days.

Should beginners start with the RDL or the deadlift?

The RDL is often the easier way to learn the hip hinge, because you start standing with the bar already in your hands. Once pushing your hips back feels natural, add the deadlift from the floor. Either way, start light and film a set from the side.

Why do I feel RDLs in my lower back instead of my hamstrings?

Usually the bar drifts away from your legs, or you round your back to reach lower. Keep the bar touching your thighs, push your hips back, and stop when your hamstrings are fully stretched, even if the bar is still above mid-shin.

More comparisons

All exercise comparisons