Pull Up and Lat Pulldown, side by side

Pull Up vs Lat Pulldown

Short answer

Do both, and alternate them. The pull-up builds the strength to move your own body. The lat pulldown trains the same pull with a weight you pick, so you can get good sets in at any level, including before your first pull-up.

Pull Up

Lean on the pull-up once you can do about 5 strict reps, when getting better at moving your own body is the goal, or when you train without machines.

How to do it

Lat Pulldown

Lean on the lat pulldown while you can't do a pull-up or can only do a few, when you want more sets than your pull-ups allow, or when you want to add weight in small steps.

How to do it

How they differ

What movesPull Up: Your body, up to the barLat Pulldown: The bar, down to you while you stay seated
LoadPull Up: Your bodyweight, plus a belt or minus a band or machineLat Pulldown: Whatever you pin on the stack
Main musclesPull Up: Lats, biceps and shouldersLat Pulldown: Lats and upper back, with the biceps helping
Body positionPull Up: Hanging, so you control your whole bodyLat Pulldown: Seated, with your thighs locked under a pad
Getting startedPull Up: Needs 1 strict rep, or an assisted or lowering-only versionLat Pulldown: Anyone can start at a light setting

A week that uses both

  1. Pull day 1 · Pull-ups: 3 sets, stopping each set 1 or 2 reps before you'd fail. Can't do one yet? Do 3 sets of 3 to 5 negatives instead: step up until your chin is over the bar, then lower yourself for 3 to 5 seconds.
  2. Pull day 2 · Lat pulldown: 3 sets of 8 to 12, with a weight that leaves 1 or 2 good reps in the tank. Pull the bar to your upper chest.
  3. Next week · Same plan. Add a rep to your pull-ups or a little weight to the pulldown. If you can't do a pull-up yet, try 1 strict rep every 2 weeks.

The weights don't carry over

A pull-up's load is your bodyweight. The number on the pulldown stack isn't, and the two don't convert. In one study, college men's best lat pulldown averaged 0.93 times their body weight, while their best pull-up, counting body weight plus any added weight, averaged 1.16 times. Stacks also differ between machines. Choose your pulldown weight by the reps you can do with good form, not by what you weigh.

What the research says

35 college men and 23 college women were tested for a one-rep max on the lat pull and the pull-up, with the pull-up load counted as body mass plus added weight or minus counterweight. Relative to body mass, both groups lifted significantly more on the pull-up (men 1.16, women 0.73) than on the lat pull (men 0.93, women 0.55). The two maxes were strongly related in men (r = 0.78) but not significantly in women (r = 0.44).

Source: Johnson et al., 2009, Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research

Questions

Common questions about Pull Up and Lat Pulldown.

How do I go from lat pulldowns to my first pull-up?

Keep the pulldown for volume, 3 sets of 8 to 12, and practice the pull-up itself on another day. Hang from the bar for 20 to 30 seconds. Then do 3 sets of 3 to 5 negatives: step up until your chin is over the bar and lower yourself for 3 to 5 seconds. A band or an assisted pull-up machine works too, for 3 sets of 5 to 8, with less help as the reps get easier. Try 1 strict rep every 2 weeks. Don't count on pulldowns alone: in an 8-week study where pulldown training raised pull-up reps, everyone could already do at least one (Li et al., 2025).

Can lat pulldowns replace pull-ups?

For training your back, mostly. Both are led by the lats, with the biceps helping. In one EMG study comparing chin-ups with the lat pulldown, the chin-up showed more biceps and lower-back activity on the way up, and lat activity wasn't among the differences (Doma et al., 2013). That study used an underhand chin-up grip, so treat it as close, not exact. What the pulldown can't do is teach you to move your own body, so if a pull-up is your goal, practice it too.

Why do I feel pull-ups and pulldowns in my arms instead of my back?

Your biceps help on every rep, so some arm effort is normal. Start each rep by pulling your shoulder blades down, then drive your elbows toward your hips, and use a weight you can move without leaning far back. Coaching can help, but don't expect your arms to go quiet: in a small study of 8 untrained women on the lat pulldown, technique instruction raised lat activity while biceps activity stayed the same (Snyder and Leech, 2009).

Why do my elbows or shoulders hurt during pull-ups?

Effort and fatigue in your back and arms are normal. Pain in the elbow or shoulder joint is a sign to change something. Try a neutral grip or a slightly different hand width, and lower under control instead of dropping into the hang. Swap some pull-up sets for lighter pulldowns for a while, and pull the bar to your upper chest, not behind your neck. Stop and get qualified help if the pain is sharp, lasts, or gets worse.

More comparisons

All exercise comparisons